GUIDE FOR THE JEWPLEXED
Jewplexed: Left Off Perry's Party List Follow Virtual Jerusalem on and Date Posted: 2011-08-11 18:59:17
Left off Perry's party list On a Shabbat in August, Governor Rick Perry of Texas hosted a National Day of Prayer, and Jews were not invited. The event, held in Reliant Stadium in Houston drew about 30,000, and was broadcast on Christian cable channels. Left off the invite list again, why did this seem so familiar? Prior to the event, the Anti-Defamation League released a protest letter signed by over 50 Houston area clergy and community leaders. In part it said: "This religious event is not open to all faiths, as its statement of beliefs does not represent religious diversity...Governor Perry has a constitutional duty to treat all Texans equally regardless of race, religion or ethnicity...We believe our religious freedom is threatened when a government official promotes religion, especially one religion over all others." During the twelve minute address to the crowd, Perry who apparently is contemplating a run for president is quoted in the Huffington Post as saying: "Father, our heart breaks for America. We see discord at home. We see fear in the marketplace. We see anger in the halls of government and, as a nation, we have forgotten who made us, who protects us, who blesses us." I don't think that many Jews, regardless of denomination, are that forgetful. We know why we're here. What we have forgotten, though, is where a certain brand of American anti-Semitism can come from. I too had forgotten, until Perry's call of Christians to prayer, jogged my memory. That's when it hit me. This current politico-Christian co-dependence reminded me of my school days behind the Orange Curtain of ultra conservative Orange County, California. In the 1960's, the county's mix of right wing politicians, and evangelical churches challenged my Jewish identity. In the heart of that county was my home in Anaheim, the city of Tomorrowland-- as long as tomorrow did not include public schools, labor unions, or sex education; three things the local papers railed against regularly. As a teenager I even questioned if that Christian and conservative tomorrow land included a place for my Jewish family. And I had reason to wonder. Creating an atmosphere where only the right dare breathe, (and Jews only take short breaths) were bedrock right politicians like State Senator John G. Schmitz (who revealed later that he fathered two illegitimate kids) and Congressman James B. Utt (who wanted the US out of the UN and civil rights legislation nixed), clergy like Melodyland Christian Center's Pastor, Ralph Wilkerson, and even right wing cause donors like Knott's Berry Farm's founder Walter Knott. Some now may worry that even though Perry did not talk about politics at the Houston event, as a public servant he violated the concept of separation of church and state. In Orange County in the 60's that crossing of boundaries bothered no one. In public elementary school, I remember we had a program of Christian education called, "Religious Release." Every few weeks students would be allowed to leave school to attend a class of religious instruction that was taught in a trailer parked adjacent to the school. During that time, I remember whiling away the time by playing games with the remaining few students. When the release students returned, I also remember having a small plastic crucifix that the student had received as a gift, pushed in my face. In high school, Christian outreach continued on the public dime. I recall time being cut from my public high school classes, so a Christian rally could be held in the school gym during school time. Acts to make Jews feel isolated and unwanted were not limited to school. My wife, who also grew up in Anaheim, remembers having the shape of a swastika burned into her front lawn. Meanwhile, our Christian neighbors attended church, prayed for salvation, and John Schmitz joined the anti-Semitic John Birch Society. But why dust off all these unpleasant memories? That was all in the way-back-when. Right?
Edmon J. Rodman has written about making his own matzah for JTA, Jewish love music for the Jerusalem Post, yiddisheh legerdemain for the Los Angeles Jewish Journal, a Bernie Madoff Halloween mask for the Forward, and what really gets stuck in the La Brea Tar Pits for the Los Angeles Times. He has edited several Jewish population studies, and is one of the founders of the Movable Minyan, an over twenty-year-old chavura-size, independent congregation. He once designed a pop-up seder plate. In 2011 Rodman received a First Place Simon Rockower Award for "Excellence in Feature Writing" from the American Jewish Press Association."
Comments Posted:
Srsly.....
Date: 2011-08-12 05:07:50
By: Terry
Ooooooooo! Oooooooo! Lookie this!
http://atlasshrugs2000.typepad.com/atlas_shrugs/2011/08/president-obama-honored-the-sacrifices-that-muslim-americans-have-made-for-the-country.html
So Perry invites all faiths, you choose to feel left out because you didn\'t get an engraved invitation, no one did, everyone was welcome, but what Obama did for 3 years in a row is OKAY?
Gosh...Obama hates Israel and honors sacrifices Muslims have made for this country, and you have a problem with PERRY???? Someone needs to get right with G-D. Yeah, check the dates...the party was while we were sleeping and the speech was from the last lovefest.
Sheesh!
WTF!
Date: 2011-08-12 06:10:31
By: cuchieddie
I\'m a secular Jew living in Orange County and I am a Conservative voter. My tendency is to vote for the person I feel is best qualified to lead my country and none of them have been leftists or progressives. Look where we are now because of their great leadership. I also support a candidate who supports Israel 278 % and your boy oblamba isn\'t the won. Oblamba is an anti-semite, hates the white man and in particulars hates the country he is supposed to be leading. Oh and you\'re an idiot.
shameful
Date: 2011-08-12 06:27:59
By: Jenifer
Why in God\'s name would you stir up such nonsense?? Do you know the difference between Christian celebration and Jewish celebration...do you write about Jews hating Christians when they are not invited to Shabbat. Shame on you for inciting hatred...shame on you!
Mr
Date: 2011-08-12 06:28:14
By: GOLDSTEIN M
That will do it. I will not waste my vote to him.
Date: 2011-08-12 06:35:07
By: Carol Jaffe Weiss
Come on Ed, think about what you have said. Regarding the kids leaving class to attend religious study while you were left out, were you attending a private catholic school at the time? Bet so. There were no invitations to see Perry. Christians come in all religions. Had you gone, I can guarantee you that you would have been offended if anyone mentioned Jesus as their savior. Would you prefer our current Muslim President and his atheiast cronies? Be a man and quit whinning. The current administration is anti semetic as shown by the total disregard and disrespect shown to Israel\'s President. Think man ! Now how about a public apology for going much too far left on this one. Let\'s get back to caring about our Country and our children. Let go of crying about something you could have participated in had you chosen to.
Date: 2011-08-12 06:52:51
By: Christa Talbott
What a waste of space on this website. How in the world do you come up with such nonsense! This was a day of prayer for Christians! He left out a lot of religions because he dedicated that day to Christians. Not a national day of prayer that Obama so destroyed, and made it a national day of muslim prayer. If you have issues, go on that one. I\'m sure you will get a lot of agreements on that issue!
Perhaps you need to reevaluate the situation and understand what you said was a blatant lie and slap in the face of Jews. Get your act together! I\'m voting for Perry because he stands for whats right in America, and if he wants to base a day of Christian prayer, so be it! I\'m in! Sorry to burst your bubble!
Date: 2011-08-12 15:19:57
By: forest hunter
The constant hypocrisy and dual standards are nothing new for the clueless morons who write this kind of inane babbling, an all too typical conservative bashing lie. It merely demonstrates the innumerable reasons why the *progressive left* have yet to accomplish a single thing worthwhile for the betterment of man. And perhaps a qualifier to enroll with welfare.
Date: 2011-08-12 01:03:10
By: Samuel
Everyone is aware of the Muslim inspired
tragedy of the Twin World Trade Towers a
decade ago ,but don,t expect the lying deceitful leftist Democrats to harp on ab
out this ,it might just cost them the 20
12 November Presidential elections ?
@ Dan
Date: 2011-08-11 23:18:19
By: Cynthia
Absurd! I think not Dan. Why did\'nt Perry call for *all Americans* to pray for our nation? The answer is very clear to me, you don\'t want to recognize his way of separating Americans. This! disgusts you!!! WHY DAN???? because Jews were deliberately left out, and we\'re not allowed to express our opinion\'s? You made a remark regarding your constant support of Israel, then go on to say; \"keep this kind of crap up and they may not\"- this threat of yours is just the kind of garbage that absolutely makes my skin crawl.Who do you think that you are with this threatening garbage? Do you actually think that your threat is so powerful, that Israel is going to fold if we don\'t have the likes of you, standing behind us? Perry is showing his true colors early on, which is great, this way we Jews, have no guessing games to play.
Right.... and wrong.
Date: 2011-08-11 20:25:41
By: Stephen Luftschein
Like so many, you make the fundamental mistake of \"separation of church and state\". The constitution has no such prohibition. What the 1st amendment does is prevent the establishment of an official state religion. The founders very much expected g0d to be a fundamental part of the exercise of power and government.
Next, is it the \"right\" (just like the \"left\" an anachronistic and incorrect way to categorize people. It is totalitarian/progressive vs. anarchy that is the correct scale.)
However, there is the strain in fundamentalist circles that does hold that all should be converted. Whether Perry is there, I don\'t know, but I imagine we\'ll find out soon enough.
Absurd
Date: 2011-08-11 15:57:23
By: Dan
This was the most slanted article. It is absurd to accuse Perry of being against the Jews because he called on \"Christians\" to pray for the nation. Did he call all other religions to join EXCEPT for the Jews? NO, he did not. And what on earth does that have to do with American public education in the 60\'s? I constantly support Israel and their right to exist as they choose in THEIR homeland. I hate what has been done to them. But this article is stupid and just trying to cause hate by some left wing writer . It disgusts me. Most Americans support Israel. Keep this kind of crap up and they may not. The very people this article is complaining about are THE people that stand up for the Jews and Israel.
Date: 2011-08-11 15:48:04
By: Terry Lowenstein
Shame on you. How could a person who is supposed to be intelligent, totally miss the boat. Not a single thing you said is a statement of truth. For you, it may be a true statement, however, and that\'s just frightening.
BTW, I live in Orange County and have no idea what you\'re talking about and neither does my husband. Stop making stuff up. You\'ve made yourself look like a moron. I\'ll bet if you looked in that closet over there you\'d find a crucifix out to get you.
Remarkable....why don\'t you pay attention to the one religion that really IS out to get us? Oh, wait...you feel sorry for them, don\'t you?
Date: 2011-08-12 07:00:41
By: Jennifer
HEY GOLDSTEIN....if you base your voting on an article like this...STAY HOME!!!
Goldstein
Date: 2011-08-12 08:02:11
By: Carol Jaffe Weiss
Dan has it right Goldstein. The Christians are standing beside Israel and will to the end. The left Muslim President and his aethist friends and administration insulted the leader of Israel. Don\'t fool yourselves anylonger. They will continue to support Palestine until there is a war to end wars. Think for yourself Goldstein, how do you want this to end?
oecuWXSqeX
Date: 2011-08-18 23:45:27
By: Bert
Wow! Great tnhiikng! JK
Not Made Up!
Date: 2011-08-18 19:54:15
By: Wendy
I was so glad to read that someone else had the \"Religious Release\" experience in school in Anaheim. I clearly remember from 2-6 grade sitting once a week alone with the Asian boy in the class as everyone left for an hour a week for Catholic or Protestant\"Religious education.\" It was a waste of my time and it created a feeling of separatism and isolation. In high school in Anaheim my biology teacher gave extra credit points for attending an early morning Christian bible meeting. I attended one day because I wanted the points as well. The teacher was surprised by my presence and questioned whether or not I could have the extra points. I complained to the principal and the points and the meetings ended. By the way Governor Perry invited all Christians not all Americans.
eBmlCrrh
Date: 2011-08-19 10:12:01
By: Maribeth
Unbelievable how well-written and infromatvie this was.
Shomer Shabbos
Date: 2011-09-02 09:17:34
By: Diana Connan Forgy
Had it occurred to you that, since the rally took place on Saturday, any Jew attending it would have desecrated Shabbos and any invitation from Perry to Jews to attend would have encouraged them to desecrate Shabbos? One should look further into Gov. Perry\'s motivations and determine whether his actions were belittling or respectful. And since every Jewish source from Pirkei Avos to the Chofetz Chaim and on enjoins us to judge every man\'s actions favorably, perhaps the author should not be quite so quick to take offense.
Jewish Texan
Date: 2011-09-10 19:11:48
By: Laurie
I thought I had heard it all until I saw this article. Rick Perry has a long history of absolutely unshakeable support for Israel, which is actually the norm for religious Christians. I have lived in Texas all my life, among evangelical Christians. You will NEVER meet a group of people more committed to Israel - never. You criticize Rick Perry because he is Christian and prays with Christians. What??? How bigoted can a person be? Don\'t Jews pray with Jews? Doesn\'t each religion have the right to pray freely with whom they choose? Doesn\'t the fact that Rick Perry can pray freely as he chooses protect the right of Jews to pray freely as we choose? Rick Perry has a record of defending the right of Jews in Texas to practice their religion freely. He signed a law making it illegal for neighborhood associations to ban the displaying of mezuzahs on doors (as a condo complex in Houston was doing). The only stipulation? The mezuzah cannot be over 25 feet tall. (In other words, Texas wanted an exclamation point on that law.) Regarding the quote from Rick Perry\'s address in your piece, where exactly is the antisemitism in those words??? If that prayer was said by a Rabbi, would you object? Before you condemn Rick Perry, for Israel\'s sake, please take a long hard look at President Obama\'s attitude toward Israel. If you do, Rick Perry will shine so bright, you\'ll need sunglasses to keep looking. Why was President Obama\'s approval rating among Israeli Jews once 4% (yes, four)? What do Israeli Jews know that American Jews don\'t?? I think that\'s worth exploring, and I think it\'s time for Jews to stop knee-jerking in fear when their Christian friends decide they would like to pray.
Jewish Texan
Date: 2011-09-10 20:11:13
By: Laurie
Wow! I just read a line in your piece I must have brushed by the first time. You said, \"In the 60\'s, the county\'s mix of right wing politicians and evangelical churches challenged my Jewish Identity.\" Like you, I grew up in the 60\'s, in my case often the only Jewish child in small town Texas public schools full of evangelical Christians. Today and back then, NOTHING could challenge my Jewish identity. Your Jewish identity is built from your relationship with G-d, your family, and the Jewish people. If your Jewish identify was or is that fragile, I hope you reexamine things. The beliefs others around you have about labor unions and sex education are entirely irrelevant to your identity as a Jew, and they certainly shouldn\'t threaten it. No wonder Rick Perry\'s Christian prayer meeting scares you. Things are scary when you\'re walking on shaky ground. I am a Jew, and neither the prayers of Christians nor the beliefs of any politicians are any challenge at all to that. I am happy to allow Rick Perry to pray as he chooses. I fully intend to do the same.
Jewish Texas
Date: 2011-09-10 21:46:17
By: Laurie
I so apologize for going on and on. It\'s really difficult not to, considering the content of your article. I just read your piece to a friend, a Jewish transplant to Texas. He was so disgusted it actually made me laugh. I\'m writing this for him. He wants to know how you can actually seriously associate Rick Perry with anything that happened to you 40 or 50 years ago in Orange County, CA??? Rick Perry was a preteen or teenager in Paint Creek, TX then. What a stretch!!!! And, we\'re both having trouble figuring out exactly what you went through then that was so traumatizing. Having \"a small plastic crucifix\" once pushed in your face by another young child?? Really scary stuff there. The fact that \"every FEW weeks\" you were left playing games with a few friends while some other students went to a religious class?? Big deal. If you didn\'t breathe deeply, don\'t blame someone else. Doesn\'t seem like anyone was stopping you to us.
Gov Perrys religious speech
Date: 2011-09-19 14:41:26
By: Bernard Weiner
I grew up in the forties when there was really antisemitism. The schools sang christmas carols etc. It did not affect my Judaism at all. I remember a questionaire which was handed out to students attempting to find out their attitudes towards other religions and different ethnic types. One question was \"would you marry a Russian jew?\" I put down yes. However, I did not marry a Russian jew. Instead I married a German Jew. That question was not on the questionaire.
Ridiculous Article
Date: 2011-10-12 10:38:30
By: Simon
I\'m Jewish and I also went to a school where most of the kids were Christian or Catholic. Yes, at times I did feel left out and yes, there were times where I and others who were not Christian, may have been picked on or bullied. It\'s simply a natural occurrence when you are a minority, especially amongst children.
I later in life went to an all-Jewish school, but I can assure you that if there were a couple of non-Jews in the school, they would also feel how I felt and perhaps even have been picked on. It\'s human nature.
The problem with your article is that you seem to draw from personal unfortunate and common experiences in your past and then shockingly, take to compare what Rick Perry arranged and apply your past ill feelings towards it.
There was nothing wrong with what Rick Perry did. If he was Jewish and arranged a day of prayer at Temple, would you then start complaining that no Christians were invited? Totally ridiculous!
I hope that those who read this article do not think that this is a common way of thinking amongst us Jews.
Mr.
Date: 2011-10-17 11:26:51
By: Alfred Mutungi
I have read the responses by the nonJew Americans and it scares me that so much of Jews was expressed in the articles. I am a Ugandan and a Chritian. When one rises to the national leadership as Perry has done, one needs to be sensitive and deliberate about every action they take keeping in mind that ppo will misconstrue their actions and words and read in between the lines whatever they will. While we can\'t fault Perry for calling only Chritians to prayer, it would have perhaps been much better to call all Americans to prayer.